How much is a Mammy cookie jar worth?

How much is a Mammy cookie jar worth?

Retail value for the old jar with worn paint is under $200. Auction results show the jars selling for $40 to $160. Remember that when buying, dealers pay half or less. We saw 33 McCoy mammy jars, including many obvious fakes, listed on eBay.

Are all McCoy vases marked?

McCoy pottery, had no identifying marks at all. Relatively early though, the procedure of marking their wares with a style number was adopted. These solitary numbers were incised into the into the body of the ware.

Is Hull and McCoy pottery the same?

Original Little Red Riding Hood cookie jars were made by Hull Pottery, not McCoy. There are also widespread fakes marked Brush McCoy. Many of the new pieces with the Brush McCoy mark were also made by other potters including Hull and Shawnee. Original McCoy turtle flower holders were produced during the 1940s.

What is the oldest cookie jar?

The Brush Pottery Company of Zanesville, Ohio is generally recognized as producing the first ceramic cookie jar. The jar was green with the word “Cookies” embossed on the front.

How can you tell fake Hull pottery?

Know that Hull pottery has two sets of markings: pre-1950 and post-1950. The pre-1950 pieces are marked: “HULL USA” AND “HULL ART USA” and may have a paper label as well. Post-1950 pieces are marked: “HULL” in large script or block lettering.

What is my McCoy cookie jar worth?

McCoy Cookie Jar History Several rare cookie jar examples from McCoy pottery sell for hundreds or thousands of dollars, like this “Freddie the Gleep” cookie jar that sold for $800 in late 2021 on eBay. However, most cookie jars sell between $30 – $80 when they are a common design in good condition.

How do people make fake cookie jars with the McCoy Mark?

What unscrupulous people do in their attempt to defraud buyers is, select a jar of their choice and make a mold of it, with the original mark removed, if any, and replace it with the McCoy mark. The modified mold results in a cookie jar that has a McCoy mark on it. Some unsuspecting buyers assume that the jar is authentic because it marked McCoy.

How many black mammy cookie jars did McCoy Pottery make?

McCoy Pottery only made two Black Mammy Cookie Jars. Both jars are widely reproduced which has caused values to come down quite a bit over the last few years. A jar with good cold paint is hard to find. This is the second mold used by McCoy, but there were several variations on the words on the front of the dress.

Are Little Red Riding Hood cookie jars made by McCoy?

Original Little Red Riding Hood cookie jars were made by Hull Pottery, not McCoy. There are also widespread fakes marked Brush McCoy. Many of the new pieces with the Brush McCoy mark were also made by other potters including Hull and Shawnee.

What is a fake Cookie Jar?

A fake is a pottery piece that is marked, as being a “McCoy” but the piece was never actually made by the NMPC at all. For example, there are a few well-known cookie jar fakes, such as Little Red Riding Hood and the more recent Snow White.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xy2U7DMcuUQ